18 Comments Posted by Felicity
https://imgur.com/a/L2kWh9m
https://youtu.be/PgxxWwgRYXk
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
Nigh unrecognizable. That's all I can say about how Halcyon looks from the courtyard looking southwest now. The entire east wing is basically rubble piles, as well as half of the middle section. I also arrived to a nasty surprise. Hale House is gone. I guess they threw out whatever plans they had to make it a visitor's center. That means that every part of Bennett that wasn't repurposed back in the eighties has been, or is being, erased. To say I'm displeased is an understatement.
Watching Halcyon be torn down was a very upsetting experience, and I owe it to my composure that I didn't start crying while filming. Though every sound of falling stone and rending board broke my heart more and more. Still, she refused to go down without a fight. Despite the machinery tearing into the structure, nothing collapsed of its own volition. Even without anything surrounding them, the chimneys still stood tall. Another thing that I won't forget is the smell. The wind was blowing towards me, and it didn't smell like when the dorms were taken down, or the mold and poison that people who've gone inside have told about. Instead, it smelled of freshly sawn wood and antiques. That was the worst part. It was almost as if she still had life left to give, despite everything, but it didn't matter anymore at that point.
Anyways, sorry about that rant. Back to business. Wanderer, you're very likely right that the place will be bare by October, but you'll have a park you can visit instead. It'll be a very lovely place for a park. I'm posting the links to today's pictures and videos at the bottom. I apologize in advance for the quality of the video. That camera can take good shots, but I guess asking for good video out of something that cheap and old is a little much. I won't be able to make it back until Monday, so I'll hope there's still something standing then. Hopefully I'll be able to finish repairing my drone by then as well.
https://imgur.com/a/gMtjWva
https://youtu.be/oPdFppeL8W4
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
R.I.P. Halcyon Hall. This fate was not deserved, but necessary nonetheless.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
https://imgur.com/a/2Ayi8Qr
Also, in the mayor's last newsletter, I discovered that they finally created a website for the park project. It has some useful information, including a semi-updated timeline.
https://www.millbrookbennettpark.org/
If that timeline remains accurate, which looks to be the case, Halcyon's demolition will start some time in the next week or so.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
Iceberg, I was aware of that collapse in the east wing, but I had no idea it was to that extent. God bless balloon framing, I guess. Letting the interior take the full brunt of deterioration while the exterior keeps up appearances is the reason why she still looks as good as she does. Still, I had no idea that things had gotten that bad. I have to admit that even for me, the self-described patron saint of lost causes when it comes to Bennett, that's too much. There was no way that Halcyon could've been anything but demolished after that collapse.
Pat, you're right that it looks better with Alumnae Hall torn down. The wrecking crew rolled Halcyon back to its 1926 configuration, with the exception of the library, by tearing it down. Still though, when Bennett was still running, it didn't look all that bad. The stucco matched Halcyon's paint then, and it didn't look completely terrible. I'd like to also dispute your point that they built it just to hide Halcyon from the street. I remembered seeing that it was planned a good fifteen years before the road was shifted to its current configuration, and found posts from the Growing up in Millbrook, NY Facebook page that matched.
https://imgur.com/a/9LPbrf2
I wasn't in the Bennett administration back then, but if I had to take a guess, they chose to put it there because its location is equidistant from both wings of Halcyon and it was a spot where it would be relatively unobtrusive, at the time. Still, if I were in the Bennett administration, I think I would've tried to make it match Halcyon in more than color alone. As far as preserving the remaining stonework is concerned, yes, I'm also optimistic about the chances of preserving most, if not all of the major parts of it. I believe they'll easily be able to save that huge corner foundation beneath the porch. It looks pretty sturdy to me. The chimneys will have to come down, at least to a reasonable level where they can't be blown over, or kill someone if they fall. The biggest uncertainty for me has to be the stone arches of the porch that connect the foundation to the wooden mass of the west wing. I'm unsure if they can be saved, but I'll give the demo team a gold medal if they can manage it, as I'd really like for them to still be there. If and when any stones are knocked loose, I'd like to see them either made into some type of rock garden, or preserved for future use in the restoration of other Millbrook estates. No souvenirs for me. That whole business is beginning to remind me of the stories of Bennett's bankruptcy sale, and I'd not like to see a repeat of that.
Speaking of, I've found a whole bunch of news articles, magazines, and other odds and ends of paperwork like the two I posted above. If you'd like to see them posted, just let me know.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
https://imgur.com/a/7xfuILs
While I was there, they were cleaning up the rubble from the earlier demos. Based on that, and on the progress they've made since this video from Antiquity Echoes that was taken a week and a half ago, we have about another week left, maybe a little longer.
https://www.facebook.c...73901963&ref=sharing
I was planning, in these final days, to cap off Halcyon's existence with a big project. However, it appears that she doesn't want to be disturbed. I was planning on flying my drone through the interior, to get one final look on camera, but I couldn't fly closer than 50 feet without completely losing control of it. I tried a couple of times, but each time I tried to get any closer, it went wobbly, and when it straightened itself back out, it would be both further from the building, and pointing away from it. After the last attempt, I managed to get it back to me, but when I went to land it, it shot right out into the road as if it were possessed, and got totaled. I know when to take a hint, so if I ever manage to put it back together, it's staying far away from Bennett.
https://imgur.com/a/Q14U6EK
Pat, it's nice to know that I'm not the only one dreaming of Halcyon, though it seems our dreams differ somewhat. I have one every week or two, ever since November 2020, when I first visited. Usually it's still ruined, and usually it isn't the focus of the dream. Sometimes it is though, and occasionally it looks brand new, though those tend to be set in the past. I've even had one that felt so real, that it was as if it was a memory. Who knows, though? My dreams tend to be atypical anyways. No singing, Shakespearean, skateboarding giraffes for me.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
https://imgur.com/a/dWaIpQt
If anyone is going to check it out, I'd recommend the utmost precautions. Wear N95 masks, and set your car to recirculate. I know they're spraying it to keep the dust and debris down, but the wind shifted the wrong way while I was grabbing those pictures, and it smelled toxic. I don't even want to know what I breathed in.
I think that the proposal for moving the gazebo to the park would be a wonderful idea. Sure they could restore it and leave it at the school, but what would be the point? It would see far more use at the park anyways, I think. And this time, they can't say that it would be used as a hang out spot for drunks and other ne'er do wells like they did the last time a move was proposed. It is crazy that it takes that much red tape just to fix a gazebo, but I see how it got to this point. They neglected it until it was too hazardous to work on, which seems to be a running theme in the village. Now it's a miniaturized version of the Halcyon situation of years past. Times have certainly changed, that's for sure. I have half a mind, some days, of relocating to Millbrook and attempting to shift the wind's direction back to what it used to be. The other half knows better, and that there's no going back. That's the one I tend to listen to.
Also, when you said "those of us whose dreams are occasionally haunted by this ghost ship wonder", did you actually mean that you dream about Halcyon sometimes? I'm just curious to see what other people's experiences are.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
https://www.theharlemvalleynews.net/?p=59142
They're not going to touch Halcyon until some time in December, and now Hale House will be spared the wrecking ball. They're thinking about using it as a visitor's center. I'm quite happy with that outcome, as the more of Bennett that gets saved, the better. I'm not sure why they're delaying the demo by two months instead of going full speed ahead, but you shouldn't look a gift horse in the mouth, so I'm not going to question it.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
https://imgur.com/a/s4qSrPO
Sorry if the quality isn't the best. I don't think the workers wanted me poking around, and I wasn't going to stick around to find out.
Pat, I was also just making a guess on when it would be finished, and I apologize if it seemed like something else. You're right that all of this has taken so much longer than anyone would've thought. But I think that whatever forces were at work causing all of the slowdowns, financial failures, and abandonment there don't have the influence they used to. If anything, this seems to be going faster than it should, and unless something comes from left field, this should all run like clockwork.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
Speaking of the presentation, I've finally managed to view it in its entirety. Based on what I've seen it appears your estimate of 3 years might be a little long, Pat. They want to have it all cleared out by January 8th, and building a park shouldn't take too long after that. I'm going to call an end date by this time next year. Earlier if we have a warm winter and/or spring. Work should already be underway as I write this, but they're not planning to bring down Halcyon until early October. It may take up to a month for them to fully demolish and truck her out, so there'll be plenty of time for spectating. The demolition process all looked clean, well organized, and above board to me, so it should be relatively safe (I hope).
Ultimately, I can't find any faults with it. They're planning on using as much of the foundation as they can save, and there should be a Bennett tribute or memorial there in the future. Apparently the old amphitheater is still there up by the art buildings, and they're going to save it. They also appear to have listened to your ideas, Pat, as there's plans for a rail trail and bandshell there in the future. And as much as I hate to admit it, Bennett and Halcyon's sacrifice is a noble one. I was quite pleased with the plans for the park and Thorne Building. I just wish it didn't have to be one or the other, but it was always going to end this way, wasn't it?
Here's the link to the presentation, so everyone can see it for themselves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OYOwvakxOV8
Just a word of warning, the audio is anywhere from manageable to terrible, but I could understand most of it. Use the captions if necessary, they help a little.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
You're right, Pat, that you're not supposed to take things from haunted houses, because they might have spirits attached to them. I'm not sure that Halcyon is as haunted as people say though. I think it's more a case of people telling stories to give it a reputation that fits its appearance. If there are any ghosts there, they'd probably be the spirits of upper class teenage girls. I could think of much worse things to have haunting your house than that.
As for Exmoore, thanks for pointing out that it was for sale. After taking a look at the listing, I can't really understand why it changes hands as frequently as you say it does. It's really a beautiful place, especially with the park that's being put in. I could only think of a few reasons why people might not be happy with it. The first is, I could see Halcyon through one of the windows in the photos, but that "problem" will be gone soon. Maybe it's haunted? After her death, Miss Bennett's body and funeral were held there. But again, I could think of worse. The last thing I could think of, is that being on the old Bennett campus gives me some intense feelings. I don't know if that happens to everyone, or if it's just me being a little odd. If it does happen to everyone, maybe they get overwhelmed living there long term? Those are my guesses.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
As far as demolition goes, I've seen small houses get flattened in an hour or two, so it might take a day each for most of the buildings. Maybe a couple of days for Alumnae Hall. Halcyon will be completely different. The sheer size of it, the structural integrity, and the amount of contaminants will probably add up to a lengthy process. I don't want to be there for it, but something is telling me that I should. It should be safe enough, especially with a good mask. I mean, the workers have to be there, and with everyone who lives in the condos, they must have to be very careful. If I were to be there, I'd probably be sitting up on the hill near Exmoore, staying off of their property of course. If worse comes to worse, I also have access to a drone with a 1/4 mile range.
I'm not sure whether or not I'd actually want a souvenir. As much as I'd want to save a piece of Halcyon from going to the trash heap, it wouldn't be right or respectful. It just feels like looting or grave robbing to me, though I don't think less of anyone who wants to, especially now. Maybe my mind will change once it's all said and done.
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
I think you're right that they're serious this time around. It seems like everyone involved has their seal of approval on it, and with such an aggressive timeline, they're not messing around. They've also upped security in the area. I noticed a great big security camera on the front gate in the pictures from the Journal, that wasn't there in mid-May. I was kind of anticipating something like this being announced since I saw the paving notice for Bennett Common Way and Exmoor Lane about a week ago. Where I live, we have main roads in worse shape that still aren't getting attention. I figured something was up, but I wasn't expecting it so soon. However, this is the third or fourth time that it's been scheduled for demolition since this website went up, so you never know.
I'm still holding out hope. Call me naive, call me a fool, but there's still a chance, however slim, for Halcyon to be saved. As long as there's someone who hasn't given up, it'll still exist. Perhaps they'll change their minds in a month, and decide to renovate instead of raze. I'd still like to see this plan go through if they don't though. It's the best of what's available, and much better than those that came before. I stumbled across some renderings of the previous condo plans, and they were terrible, to say the least. I sort of know how you feel, Pat. I think the park plan is a good one, but I'm not ready to say goodbye yet, and I've only been here since November. You've been around Halcyon for your entire life.
On a happier note, for those of us not ready to leave the past behind, I've finished updating the Bennett in Color album. It now includes over 100 images, including some really good ones from the '62 and '64 yearbooks.
https://imgur.com/a/zd0N27g
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
Pat, that 3D model of Halcyon sounds like a great idea, and I'd love to see it when you finish. I'm glad you liked the colorized photos. I should have an update coming to that album before too long, as I've found a lot more pictures, among other things. More recently, however, I've been helping the Bennett Swans find and digitize their old albums. So far, we've managed to get three out of the six of them.
https://soundcloud.com.../bennett-black-swans
https://soundcloud.com...sets/show-us-the-way
https://soundcloud.com...3/sets/all-that-jazz
- Location: Bennett School for Girls (view comments)
- Gallery: Close Calls
https://tinyurl.com/mrxrnhn9
That was Saturday. I went down on Friday, expecting to see that, but I guess I was a day early. I took pictures anyways, and met a Bennett alum who stopped by as I was leaving. I planned on taking a drone video, with a different one, since my first is still in pieces. However, the exact same thing started happening, in the exact same place. When I got it back, it appeared to be perfectly functional, aside from not responding to any outside input. All I can do is shrug, and tell you that I'm sorry there's no video this time, but some force has decided that for me, Bennett is a no-fly zone. Anyways, here are Halcyon's final pictures.
https://imgur.com/a/pdnCB0e