Comments
- Location: Eastern State Penitentiary (view comments)
- Gallery: Behind the Walls
- Location: Eastern State Penitentiary (view comments)
- Gallery: Behind the Walls
- Location: Eastern State Penitentiary (view comments)
- Gallery: Behind the Walls
- Location: Eastern State Penitentiary (view comments)
- Gallery: Behind the Walls
- Location: Eastern State Penitentiary (view comments)
- Gallery: Behind the Walls
- Location: Foxboro State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Transitions
- Location: Northampton State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Mental Floss
1) Were the experiments done in the bathtub, or was the tub used to clean the patients afterward?
2) If you don't know what kind of experiments they were, how do you know there were any experiments at all?
3) If you can't describe the "experimental juices," how do you know there were any juices at all?
4)If these barbaric experiments were done, why weren't the records destroyed? Obviously this sort of experimentation would have to remain secret, but the records were just dumped in an old farmhouse?
5) Just how did you become the one--the few-- who knows all these dreadful secrets? With all the class action lawsuits that led to deinstitutionalization, wouldn't some lawyer have already come across this experimentation and used it to help win the case?
Now a few facts:
1) There was a strong eugenics movement in the US, which the National Socialist Party under Hitler took to the gross atrocities of the "Final Solution." By the time the Nazis were in full force committing crimes against humanity, the eugenics movement in the US was in decline.
2) Involuntary sterilization operations were done in the US, made legal under state laws and upheld by the Supreme Court in a majority opinion written by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes. There were a few doctors who thought that it was best to withhold treatment from newborns with severe abnormalities, but this never went further than a few isolated cases. While there were plenty of people who wanted to prevent individuals with mental illness, and more particularly those with mental retardation, from having children, there was never any proposal to "eliminate" people already living. An excellent book on these topics is "War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race" by Edwin Black.
3)There were experiments done without the kind of informed consent and other ethical safeguards we consider mandatory today, but those experiments were not exclusive to psychiatric hospitals and institutions for people with developmental disabilities (think of the Tuskegee airmen or the studies of deliberate air contamination over towns and schools, etc.).
Finally, it is always a good idea to question, to verify, to THINK. Sometimes people take a subject that has a grain of truth, and expand on it until it fills a whole silo, just to see how much outrageous BS they can get others to accept. Believing and spreading this kind of garbage does nothing to further the cause of better care for people with mental disabilities. It only makes people skeptical of everything you say, and plenty of regrettable actions really did happen. There's no need to embellish with such far-fetched nonsense that serves only to diminish the real suffering that did occur.
sorry so long. I tried to not say anything, but the more I thought about it, the more I had to respond. At least I finally figured out how to arrange my posts in paragraphs instead of one big block :-)
- Location: Foxboro State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Transitions
- Location: The Ladd School (view comments)
- Gallery: Brownfields
- Location: Buffalo State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Night Photography
Regarding volunteering--most community mental health centers and hospitals have organized volunteer programs and welcome people with a sincere interest in helping. Typically a criminal background check is required, as well as training in confidentiality, client rights, prevention of abuse and neglect, etc.
Special Olympics (for people with developmental disabilities) uses volunteers. Many communities have baseball, soccer, or swimming programs for children with developmental disabilities. Advocacy on behalf of those with mental illness or developmental disabilities is always welcomed--letters, phone calls to legislators, speaking at public hearings, etc. Contact the human resources department of the organization to let them know of your interest .
- Location: Foxboro State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Transitions
- Location: Château de Mesen (view comments)
- Gallery: Break
Especially since they are both covered in dirt.
- Location: Clairvaux Tuberculosis Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Restraints
- Location: Clairvaux Tuberculosis Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Hello Again
- Location: Clairvaux Tuberculosis Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Hello Again