3,181 Comments Posted by Lynne
- Location: Buffalo State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Night Photography
- Location: Fuller State School and Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Disturbed
Torture is generally defined in terms of the intent. If the therapy or treatment was an attempt to help people get better, even if painful, we are less likely to call it torture. Braces on children's teeth hurt, but they generally make the child look better in time. Doesn't make the child feel any better at the time, but the intent is there for long-term improvement. Plastic surgery - cutting someone's face apart and sewing it back together - is an intrusive, painful procedure, but most people in society don't call it torture (unless they actually have to watch it happen <G>).
As time passes and we develop new ways of doing things (or new ethics and societal mores develop) we tend to look backwards and redefine things according to what is relevant and known NOW.
In our society in the 1700 and 1800's, if people exhibited any tendencies toward psychiatric illness they used to be condemned to attics, cellars, outdoor sheds, jails, and prisons where they were caged, chained to the wall, had little food, and had little to no exposure from the heat and cold because it was believed they could not feel pain. Many became de facto indentured servants to others. Many wandered the streets being expelled from town after town, being chased, ridiculed, and physically attacked by children and others, and often starving to death or dying from exposure to the elements. The mental health movement of the 1800s was an attempt to get people out of these terrible conditions and off somewhere they could be safe - a "haven" or "asylum." They received a place to live, medical treatment, food and medicines, and attempts were made at "restoring" their senses.
As time went by, more and more people were sent to these places but the legislature did not keep up with providing enough money to allow these places to provide the minimums necessary for comfort, much less for treatment. The people in society (that's you and me) demanded we get these "weirdoes" off the street and away from us, but we weren't nice enough to vote to give the "weirdoes" enough money to be comfortable, i.e., receive some of the basics of life.
It wasn't the hospitals being "torturous." It was US not caring enough as a society about the people we asked to have hidden away - WE didn't have the conscience to demand that enough money was spent to take care of these very vulnerable folks.
Then someone came in and decided it WAS the fault of all the hospitals and demanded they be shut down. So they were. And now where all all the people they "freed?" Back in the streets with no shelter or food, being set on fire by punks for "fun", back in jails and prisons, back at home with a family that is slowly disintegrating because they have no resources to take care of their loved one.
Kinda makes a body wonder what "torture" really is, don't it? ;-)
- Location: Dixmont State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Departure
- Location: Buffalo State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Night Photography
- Location: Pilgrim State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Emptiness
Thanks, also, for the great reference for the "SomaSafe Enclosure" bed. I am always looking for new adaptive equipment to try out to make life easier for our folks. :-)
- Location: Fuller State School and Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Disturbed
. . . if I thought my old osteoporotic bones wouldn't crack when I went to grab at you.
:-(
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: Norwich State Hospital (view comments)
- Gallery: Lockdown
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum
- Location: North Wales Hospital (Denbigh Asylum) (view comments)
- Gallery: The Castle and the Asylum